ALJDEC
02F-T0537-ROC · Registrar of Contractors · 2002-06-28
IN THE OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE HEARINGS
|Ann and Thomas Picard, | | Case No.: T02-0537 | | | |Docket No.: 02F-T0537-ROC | |Complainants, | | | | | |RECOMMENDED DECISION OF | | | |ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE | |vs. | | | | | | | | | | | |License No. 165975, Class B-03 of | | | |Daniel Gene Nordbrock d.b.a. | | | |North River Construction (Indiv), | | | | | | | |Respondent. | | | | | | |
HEARING: Wednesday, June 19th, 2002; 9:00 a.m. APPEARANCES: Complainants, Ann and Thomas V. Picard, appeared in their own behalf. Respondent, Mr. Daniel Nordbrock, appeared in his own behalf. ADMINISTRATIVE LAW JUDGE: Grant Winston. _____________________________________________________________________ The administrative hearing of this matter was held in the Office of Administrative Hearings, Tucson. Testimony was heard and other evidence admitted to the record, and, based on the entire record, the following Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Recommended Order are made. FINDINGS OF FACT
1. The respondent herein, Daniel Gene Nordbrock, doing business as North River Construction, is, and during all time material hereto was, a contractor licensed by and doing business in the State of Arizona, holding Class B-03 License number 165975. 2. Respondent is a cousin to the complainants, Ann and Thomas Picard. The complainants are a married couple residing in Sahuarita, Arizona. 3. The parties entered into a verbal contract on or about July 6th, 2001, whereby the respondent was to install cabinets, countertops and shower panels in the complainants’ Sahuarita home. 4. Very few facts of the agreement can be found since it was entirely verbal, and the parties at hearing gave contradictory sworn testimonies as to the terms of the agreement. However, some of the agreement is undisputed. 5. It is undisputed that the parties did enter into an agreement for the respondent to install the fixtures described above, and that respondent would charge complainants only the wholesale costs of the materials plus tax, and would not charge for any labor involved in the project. 6. After considerable work had been done on the project the parties fell into disagreement which caused a halt to the project on or about December 1st, 2001, and ultimately this administrative complaint against respondent’s license. 7. Complainants contend that the work was defective in many respects, that they had not received new materials, and that some of the materials were damaged. Respondent contends that he halted work on the project because he had not been paid for the materials. 8. It becomes impossible to find facts in addition to those already found owing to the verbal nature of the contract, and the parties’ contradictory testimony. Respondent offered the record an affidavit by a third party, but it yields little substantive information. 9. Complainants filed the instant complaint with the registrar on or about December 19th, 2001, complaining of respondent’s abandonment of the project, and damaged materials. 10. The complaint was assigned to Registrar of Contractors Inspector James R. Morris for inspection in the normal course of his duties. He conducted two job-site inspections which led to two separate Corrective Work Orders being issued over his signature. The first CWO was dated January 10th, 2002, and directed the respondent to correct or complete 31 items, and to complete the project according to all agreements, prints, plans specifications, and in accordance with all good workmanship practices, industry standards and applicable codes. The CWO allowed 15 calendar days for respondent to comply, which was a reasonable amount of time. 11. The second CWO was issued on February 20th, 2002, and added four items of correction for the respondent to do, and to do within 15 calendar days, which was a reasonable amount of time. 12. Complainants, in addition to their testimony, offered the record several photographs which prove that many of the materials are broken, and the work defective and incomplete in many respects. 13. Respondent declined to perform any of the corrective work, and citation and complaint issued from the registrar’s office in this case on March 21st, 2002. 14. Inspector Morris testified at the hearing, and by his testimony it is found that he conducted a pre-hearing inspection of the job site the day previous to the hearing, and none of the work ordered to be done by his CWO had been done. 15. Respondent testified that all work listed on the CWO were included in the parties’ contractual agreement as items he was to construct. He simply believes he is under no obligation to do further work until he is paid. 16. Notice is taken of the respondent’s prior license record with the Arizona Registrar of Contractors. CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. This administrative hearing was held under authority of and in accordance with A.R.S. 32-1156, and A.R.S. 41-1092. 2. The citation and complaint in this case charges the respondent with possible violations of A.R.S. 32-1154.A.7., 23. and 3. 3. A.R.S. 32-1154.A.3. prohibits a licensed contractor from violating any rule adopted by the registrar. The rule cited in the citation and complaint is A.A.C. R4-9-108, Workmanship Standards. The evidence proved that respondent violated this rule, and therefore violated the statute, by his poor workmanship in installation, and failure to complete the project, and to correct broken materials. 4. A.R.S. 32-1154.A.23. prohibits a licensed contractor from failing to take appropriate corrective action to comply with the contractors’ laws of Arizona, without valid justification, within a reasonable amount of time, after receiving a written directive from the registrar to do so. Respondent violated this statute by failing to make the corrections ordered by the inspector in the two CWOs. If respondent believes he has not been paid what he is owed, it is for him to seek redress of that grievance another time at another place. There was no good evidence from him to prove that in this case. 5. A.R.S 32-1154.A.7. prohibits a licensed contractor from engaging in any wrongful or fraudulent act as a contractor which results in another person being substantially injured. There is no evidence that respondent committed any violation of this section independent of the violations already concluded to have been committed by him. RECOMMENDED ORDER
In view of the foregoing Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law it is hereby recommended that the respondent’s Class B-03 License number 165975 shall be suspended until such time as the registrar receives written proof that the respondent has properly accomplished the corrective work set forth in the inspector’s two Corrective Work Orders. It is further recommended that if the respondent properly accomplishes the aforesaid corrective work on or before the effective date of this order (40 days after the date of service shown by the registrar’s certification on the order), then no license suspension shall take place, and Citation and Complaint number T02-0537 shall be closed. Done this day, June 21st, 2002.
______________________________________ Grant Winston Administrative Law Judge
Original transmitted by mail this ____ day of ____________, 2002, to:
Registrar of Contractors Michael P. Goldwater ATTN: Joyce Armijo 800 West Washington, 6th Floor Phoenix, AZ 85007
By ___________________________
-----------------------